I'm going to post the screen shots I just stuck on the newsgroup version of your post, Jeff, with the same comments.
I see the same things as before -
1. Chrome complains that the site is not secure because you are serving
some images (various paths to versions of favicon.png) over HTTP. (Those are the YELLOW items in your screen shot).
First screen shot shows that Chrome is satisfied with the certificate
and encryption otherwise.
2. Your web folder is not where you think it is (or else you don't have the right stuff in it), so none of the
javascript/CSS are loading (Those are the RED items in your screen shot). Check the path shown in the second screen
shot.
Did you maybe accidentally copy your sitesettings.xml file from your dev machine to your production machine?